Tuesday, April 1, 2025

Managing Mom Guilt - Big Family Activities

 Declan started practices for his spring soccer league that was sold to us as a "close travel" league. But then I got the schedule (after paying $180 for registration and $200 for uniforms), and his first game is on Nantucket. Yes, the island. As in, a one-hour drive to the ferry in Hyannis, followed by a 2-hour ferry ride to Nantucket, all for a one-hour soccer game—and then travel the whole thing backwards.

Yeah, no thanks. Declan will be skipping that first game. Luckily, the rest of the games are less than an hour away, but I’m reminded why we didn’t do travel sports for our kids until now—and only because there’s just one child who wanted to partake. Imagine trying to manage travel teams back in the day when five of them played soccer at once? Impossible.


Which brings me to one of the hardest parts about being a mom to lots of kids: trying to give the same opportunities and experiences to each child.

Now, I don’t want this to be confused with giving each child “love and attention,” which is often the reason given to not have more than a couple of kids. The secret that the world doesn’t realize is that giving children more siblings naturally gives them more love and attention. There are literally more people in the family who interact with them, care for them, play with them, and have their backs. Parents aren’t the only source of love and attention (or entertainment, for that matter), and I dare say that children from healthy, big families get plenty of support and feel loved by many—which might not always be the case in smaller families.

But while love is infinite, financial resources and hours in the day are not. And that’s where having lots of kids in activities can get tricky. Much to my husband’s dismay, my brain tends to keep track of the opportunities we gave the older kids, and I feel the need to give the younger kids the same. They don’t have to choose the exact same sports or instruments or activities, but I want them to have access to everything, and not be held back or discouraged just because we’re busier now, paying for college tuitions, or, let’s be honest, just plain older and more tired now!

JP, Andrew, Eamon, and Maggie all played soccer, basketball, track, baseball, and took swim lessons throughout their whole childhood. Once they reached middle school, they tried golf, lacrosse, volleyball, flag football, and competitive swim. In high school, they each played two or three sports per year. Andrew went on to play soccer in college, Eamon wants to do the same next year, and Maggie hopes to play volleyball in college. We’re under no delusions that they’ll be going to college on athletic scholarships. They’re good at their respective sports, play varsity at early ages, and become captains and leaders on their teams, but they are not D1 material at all. We tell them to focus on academics for those college scholarships, and they’re doing a great job at that. :)

So now we have the next three kids, who sometimes feel like our second family, thanks to the age gap and the huge difference in interests. Alexander tried soccer and basketball but didn’t last more than one season of each. He literally told us at age four that he wanted to retire from soccer. Gosh, he was so funny. Anyway, he’s always loved music, so we started piano lessons for him at age 6, and he has kept at it for the past seven years. We’re an active and (we try to be) fit family, so even though organized sports didn’t appeal to Xander, we wanted him to be physically active, and put him in competitive swim, which he loved.  He moved up to the Swim Team when he was 11. He loves swimming and quickly realized that he felt and slept better on the four days a week when he swam, so he began adding running and workout videos on the other three days. Now, he thinks he’ll run cross country in the fall (as a high schooler—where did the time go?) and then swim in the winter.

Declan is wired much more like Andrew and Eamon and wants to play all the sports, watch all the sports, talk about all the sports, live outside and never stop moving. He has a ball in his hand most hours of the day when he’s not in school. He plays soccer in the fall, basketball in the winter, runs 5ks whenever we sign him up, and also takes weekly violin lessons. I wanted to let Declan continue to play a sport this spring because he loves it, and I used to let the older kids do the same. The problem is, we now have an ice cream shop that takes up a lot of time, and signing up for spring sports takes way more communication and logistics than it used to.

My husband, who loves me very much, suggests that we don’t sign up the kids for anything this spring because, between the shop’s additional work, the season of sacraments (he’s also the DRE at our parish), our regular jobs, and just life in general, it’s already pretty hectic. As for me, who loves my kids very much, I have an extremely hard time saying no to Declan playing spring soccer, when I let the older kids play so many sports and try so many things. It doesn’t seem fair that Declan should have to suffer just because he’s the 6th kid, right? I mean, we should expect to be stressed, running here, there, and everywhere for the kids—that’s just what parents do. It’s the “season” in our lives. But for us, those seasons go on and on, because we have all of these lovely kids.

Parents of one or two children might think, “Okay, let’s buckle down and be ships passing in the night for the next five years while our kids play sports, take instruments, and have playdates.”  Then, those kids will be in high school and not depend on us in the same way. For parents of large families, those buckle-down years go on forever. And it’s hard. And it’s exhausting. And yes, it’s completely our fault! We know how it happened. ;) But just because we were open to a big family doesn’t make it easy—or make us especially equipped to handle it better than anyone else. We struggle. We overthink. We constantly assess the needs of each child. We get stressed, we get tired, and we fail often.

But, if we’re being honest, we wouldn’t have it any other way. We obviously can't imagine life without each of these sweet souls with us.  I mean, what else would we be doing with our time and money? (Insert maniacal laugh here.) We can see the future, filled with lots of grandchildren and travel plans after these hard-working years are over. Hard doesn't mean bad. So many good things come from times of struggle.   For now, as we have been for a long time, we’re in the thick of it, but at least we’re in it together.

11 comments:

  1. Similar problem here! I never signed the older kids up for sports or lessons unless it was cheap and close (occasionally swim with the city and piano) or with the elementary school ( school spirit and the fee wasn't much). We got through some hectic years with junior high sports. We don't have family close by to help with babysitting or driving, so it's all on me and my husband. Once they hit high school, I no longer have to drive to away games/meets/performances, so it's easier. My younger crew have never gotten piano lessons, and rarely had swim class. They do some activities with school ( and my baby decided he loves basketball and practices on his own,) but there are some different dynamics and personalities, and we just don't sign them up. I have a little more money now and fewer kids, but it's a real effort to make the step to join anything. I'm very tired , and I don't have the excuse of running a small business! However, part of me has gotten very cynical with respect to activities- it seems like the fees and extras just add up, the crazy distances and tournaments not worth it. There are a lot of factors going into choosing how to spend your family time, and we do the best with what we have. Hang in there! -mbmom11
    PS - I am thinking about getting 2 youngest boys piano lessons, if I can find a teacher who doesn't cost the earth!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. We are the same with having to do it all ourselves (babysitting and driving) unless it's an emergency and then we do have family to ask, but everyone is busy with their own kids stuff. It is so much easier when they are in high school and sports are right after school, and even better when they drive. I just don't want them to get to high school (where they have to play two seasons of a sport) not feeling prepared to play a sport, so we start them young.
      For piano lessons, we use the person who played at our church and bring the boys to his house, and for violin lessons, we use a coworker of Phil who is a science teacher but also plays violin and was so excited to start giving lessons. We pay $20 per kid per half hour lesson for everyone, which I think is a great price.

      Delete
  2. What a great post, Colleen, and such helpful insights.!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Elisabeth, moms are so good at having guilt no matter how many kids they have or how they run their family, huh?

      Delete
  3. Okay so I just had to Google Maps Nantucket to your area to visualize it. That's insane. Activities are the most complicated. Meredith is in cheap rec soccer with only six games... and one of them is at the exact same time as Christopher's one and only choir concert. (Which seriously. The odds of that happening...) I have only 2 kids and they each have 2 activities total and we still overlap. You're amazing for doing this seven times and don't doubt anything but!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Murphy's Law that it would overlap! Declan's first home soccer game is the same day as Brendan's first piano competition, of course it is! Luckily we have teenagers that can take Declan to his game so we can see the more important piano competition but yikes.

      Delete
  4. I totally, totally relate to this except I have already given up on keeping things "even". Just the other day I was watching Elizabeth dance around our living room and thinking that at her age (3) Greta was already signed up for dance classes and would have been preparing for her first dance recital, which she loved. But Elizabeth's main extracurricular activity is coming along to spectate her big sisters' games :) It helps me to reframe it in the context of the educational concept "fair is not the same as equal". I.e. each child should get love, attention, and opportunities that are what *they* need as an individual and it won't look the exact same for every child.

    I think if Declan's ONLY opportunity to play a sport during the year was this spring for some reason, I'd try really hard to make that happen. But I also think it's good for kids to have busier times and less structured times. I also have some friends with multiple kids who just don't do any outside activities at all and that doesn't sit well with me, so I really appreciate having you as a model for how to balance school, faith, sports and fitness!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. As much as I try not to keep things exactly even, I still keep the running tally in my head. Just last week Declan said he wanted to play golf, and we had let Eamon and Andrew play when they were his age, so I want to let him, but I'm like HOW ON EARTH CAN WE FIT THAT IN now? And of course I keep trying to figure it out logistically and financially. For now I told him "Maybe next year" as if next year will be less busy, yeah right! I agree with you about people who don't do any outside activities and I think those kids are missing out on so many life lessons and experiences. Like my big kids can just go play a pickup basketball game, frisbee game, volleyball game, soccer game, run a race, ice skate, swim, etc. and I know families whose kids don't know the rules to any sports at all. Think of how much activity and fun they are missing out on for the rest of their lives, feeling left out? It breaks my heart!

      Delete
  5. I’m a longtime reader of your blog and I just wanted to say how impressed I’ve always been about how many activities your kids get to do! They all do way more than my one son. :). From my point of view you do such a good job with that.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh thank you for the affirmation! I'm not sure if it's the area we live in, or the way I was raised, but kids seem to be very involved in a lot of things around here. I grew up playing soccer, basketball, softball, volleyball, track, ice skated, and played violin even though I'm the 5th of 6 kids so I also wanted to give my kids the opportunity to try things they wanted, within reason and financial constraints. There's like this extra pressure I feel to not "deprive" my kids because I had so many kids, ya know? I don't think I would be so worried about it if I had one or two though I'm sure my mom guilt would just creep up in other ways :)

      Delete
  6. you are an inspiration for me when it comes to keeping the kids busy!

    ReplyDelete

Talk to me...